EN | DE

When the Facts Get in the Way Of a Feel-Good Story: My Journey Through Media Accountability

tags = [, , , ]

I’ve spent the last few weeks trying to do something that should be simple in professional journalism: reconciling a viral news story with documented reality - this has involved contacting newspaper journalists, escalating to chief editors, and learning more about journalism ethics codes than I ever wanted to know.

It began when a “feel-good” human-interest piece started circulating through the international press. It was the kind of story that travels well on social media—think of a “senior citizen adopts neglected kitten” type of narrative—where the emotional payoff is high and the nuance is low, and the journalistic value is questionable at best.

The problem was that the story was fundamentally misleading. By leaving out documented facts, the press created a sanitized version of events that directly hurt someone close to me. Like reporting that a marathon runner “crossed the finish line first” without mentioning that they were disqualified for taking the train.

I’m intentionally not linking to it here, since I don’t want to draw more attention to it, but you could probably find it with a bit of research and the information in this post.

Initially I assumed that pointing out these omissions to the journalists involved would lead to a straightforward correction or removal, probably after further research. Instead, I spent weeks contacting about 50 different publications, only to find that once a narrative is performing well, the truth is often treated as secondary - especially when the story stands or falls with a simple happy ending. This describes my experience trying to get the record corrected—and what happened when the reality of the story got in the way of a feel-good narrative.

The Setup

A German regional newspaper (Ostfriesen Zeitung) published a human interest story, based on an interview with one party. It went viral - or at least viral enough to reach the Netherlands. Subsequently (but with half a month delay), Germany’s main press agency, the DPA, picked it up and wrote their own version. As did BILD and RTL. Within days, the story appeared in over fifty publications across Germany, Austria, Luxembourg, Poland, Belgium, France and Switzerland-from tabloids to serious broadsheets. Lots of positive comments. It was exactly the kind of story that travels well: at the surface a feel-good, shareable piece with a happy ending.

The problem was that key facts had been omitted. Facts that fundamentally changed the nature of the story. Facts that, if included, would have made it considerably less suitable for the “heartwarming” category. Someone close to me was an (unmentioned) party in the whole story and directly affected by what actually happened, and was now watching a sanitised fairy tale version circulate through major news outlets.

What was actually helpful was that the omitted facts were well documented, and that there was proof to back up their existence. Without this, it would have been even harder to get anyone to take the concerns seriously.

It was one thing for the story to appear in the foreign press, and initially we ignored it when it came to our attention. Then I heard through the grapevine that a Dutch journalist had seen the article and was planning to write his own version of the story. This raised the stakes - since it would possibly mean another round of omissions and misrepresentation, but this time with a much higher impact closer to home - so I decided to proactively reach out to him to ensure he had the full picture before proceeding.

Once I’d started down this path, I also decided to contact all other outlets that had already published the story - worried that the existence of it out there would continue to inspire more stories.

I reached out to each publication, explaining the situation, offering documentation and hoping for action.

The Dutch Paper: A Story That Almost Repeated

The original story was the inspiration for other journalists to write their own versions, as well a Dutch journalist planning to do so.

Since I became aware of this planned article, I reached out to him directly to provide the full context - he would only be interviewing one party otherwise. I contacted him before he traveled to Germany, in the hope that he would reconsider writing the story if he had all the facts - and would realise the story was not as rose-tinted as it first appeared.

He responded positively at first, and seemed to take the concerns seriously. He promised to contact me before publishing anything, to “alleviate the impact”.

While he may have broached the subject with the other party, in an appearance in a podcast he painted the exact same incomplete picture as the original German article. The podcast also came as a surprise to us - an acquaintance heard of it and let us know, which came as a bit of a shock.

Confronting him, he explained that he had broached the subject but implied that the other party had downplayed the omitted facts, and that he didn’t consider them significant enough to do more than mention it in passing.

At this point, it was clear that he had a particular narrative in mind and was not interested in hearing the full story. I figured I’d escalate the matter to the chief editor.

After some back and forth (the chief editor seemed to initially have skimmed my email and was ready to dismiss any facts unless there was proof), I provided documentation. They promised they would investigate, contact the other party, and make an editorial decision on what to do after that.

After that, it was quiet for a while - but eventually I heard back from the original journalist that they had decided to cancel the article entirely “because of the impact on the people involved”. This was a relief; we were thankful that they took the concerns seriously, but that wouldn’t have happened if I hadn’t been persistent.

The Wire Agency: Formal Correctness as a Shield

My first stop was a number of larger papers in Germany, hand-picked to focus on the high-quality ones. Very quickly, the editor for news articles at one of them forwarded my message to the news chief editor at the DPA - the German press agency. This was expected, since they were the source that almost everyone else had copied. I laid out the timeline, offered to provide documentation, and explained how the omissions distorted the story.

The response from their news chief was surprising. The defence essentially came down to: we never technically said anything false. Every word in the article could be defended in isolation. That the overall story created by those words was wildly distorting reality was, in their words, a matter of “moral categories” that they didn’t care about. They didn’t say that the portrayal was accurate, just that the accuracy of the image painted didn’t matter.

The analogy I used in an email to him was that of a marathon runner who is interviewed and reported to “have come across the finish first”, but where the article fails to mention that they were later disqualified for taking the train. Technically, the statement is correct - he did after all cross the finish line first - but not mentioning the other facts is a gross omission. The German press code (which by this point I had become quite familiar with) also clearly states that journalists should report the truth3 and not mislead (e.g. through omission)4 - and correct where necessary5.

Despite me purely offering facts, they described my complaint as an “emotional reaction”. Various papers later echoed this framing in their own response to me.

This was disappointing, since it meant that the DPA would not retract or correct the story - which would have meant that all other outlets would have as well.

Expanding the Effort

After this, I figured my best approach would be to contact each publication individually - after all, while the DPA originally wrote the story, each outlet made the editorial choice to publish it, and therefore bore responsibility for what appeared under their masthead.

At this point, I’d collected the URLs of over about fifty different outlets that had republished the story in a Google Sheet. There was a mix of large national papers, regional outlets, tabloids, broadcasters and some internet-only publications. I drafted a standard email explaining the situation, pointing out the specific omissions, and offering to provide documentation. I also referenced the relevant sections of the German press code (Pressekodex) that I believed had been violated. My complaint was purely factual: your paper has published an article (with link provided) that omits key facts (listed) that blatantly distort the real story.

I should note that while my e-mail explained what my relationship was to the person affected, I didn’t make it personal beyond that - all I did was point out the incorrect picture being painted, and (later in the process) cite documentation and which parts of the press code I believed had been violated.

Initially, I sent emails to the email addresses of editors (redaktion) that I could find. When I didn’t get responses, I would send reminders and eventually escalate to chief editors (chefredaktion) where possible.

The Other Papers: A Mixed Response

The responses varied widely.

Some outlets ignored me entirely, never responding to emails or acknowledging the complaints. Some responded only after multiple follow-ups and reminders. A few still haven’t responded.

A number of publications responded by immediately taking the article down without further research. Some explicitly mentioned that they weren’t legally acknowledging any wrongdoing while they did so. Some took the article down without replying at all.

Most of the responses from other editors were defensive, usually deflecting or trying to dismiss my complaint as unactionable. As I contacted more editors, the excuses shifted from the technical to the absurd. It was a game of ‘Not My Problem’ bingo:

  • The “Laundering” Defense: “We didn’t write it, we just ran what the DPA sent us” (this one came up a lot. “Yes, DPA wrote it - but you chose to publish it and are responsible.”)
  • The Copyright Red Herring: “We can’t change it, because we don’t own it” (similar - “Yes, you don’t own the copyright but you can still choose to remove it”)
  • The Bureaucratic Wall: “You have to contact the copyright owner, which is not us” (despite me never mentioning copyright, “we’re talking about journalistic ethics, nobody mentioned copyright”)
  • “Sorry, our chief editor is on vacation for the next three weeks - and we can’t do anything until he returns” (“that’s a long time to wait, maybe you can take the article down in the meantime?”)
  • The Liability Pivot: “Legally speaking, nothing in the article is false” (“I never said I was making a legal complaint - this is about journalistic ethics”)
  • The Engagement Trap: “If you’re willing to go on the record, we’ll publish a follow-up” (there are no clicks to be gained from corrections or removals - “I don’t want a follow-up, you have the responsibility to correct the existing article”)
  • The “Privacy” Irony: “A corrected story would violate your privacy” (despite the story already being out there - “you chose to put this in the public domain”)
  • The Circular Referral: “We copied this article from another newspaper, please contact them” (“that newspaper hasn’t even published the story”)

A number eventually relented and silently removed after they initially ignored me and I sent them several reminders with deadline, or after I countered their objections.

It’s hard for me to tell if any of these were genuine misunderstandings, attempts to wear me out so I would go away, or perhaps just trying to buy time so the article could get more clicks (after all, the benefits of keeping a three-week old article up are limited). One of the things that did strike me is how few journalists actually seemed to properly read and respond to the contents of the (4 paragraph) email I sent to them. Many responses replied to strawman arguments I never made.

Only a handful of journalists engaged constructively, asking for documentation or follow-up conversation. That said, most seemed primarily interested in writing a sensational follow-up story, which I declined to provide, and quickly lost interest in helping correct the record after that.

I didn’t really discover a pattern in the way publications responded. Even so-called “quality” newspapers were very reluctant to consider the concerns seriously - although they all took the article down once I escalated. BILD, a tabloid known for sensationalism, was surprisingly responsive at first - although they were clearly hoping for a followup rather than actually interested in correcting the previous article.

In the end, about 27 of the 40-plus publications removed the article entirely (at time of writing), some after reviewing the documentation I provided. I have ongoing discussions with a few more. I have filed formal complaints with the German press council about a couple of the articles - these are still pending and will take months.

The Original Paper: The Ostfriesen Zeitung

The original regional newspaper (Ostfriesen Zeitung) that published the story milked it for three follow-ups that provided very little additional substance - on top of an already lightweight story. The omissions in their article are particularly glaring, and they also include some provably false statements.

The author responded to my concerns in a similar defensive manner as the DPA, focusing on technical correctness even then used an uncommon interpretation of certain words. I contacted them after their second article, but they failed to respond - and published their third article quickly after while repeating the same falsehoods and without any further follow-up to me. The fourth article reflected on their earlier reporting and the impact, and still failed to acknowledge the omissions or correct the record.

I’ve since escalated the matter to their chief editor, Lars Reckermann, who ignored my message. He also sits on the project team advising the Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung’s programme for local journalism1.

What makes the silence awkward is that he has been fairly clear in public about what he thinks journalism owes its readers. On a 2017 panel about fake news, then chief editor of the Nordwest-Zeitung, he argued that journalists must take even more care to verify information brought to them, that the aspiration of journalistic work is always to depict the truth, and that newspapers need to get better at entering into dialogue with their readers2.

On that same panel he defended deleting reader comments, drawing a comparison to his own living room - he gets to decide who stays. But the justification he gave was specifically for contributions that are clearly unlawful, such as incitement. My own comments on the Ostfriesen Zeitung’s articles, which were polite and documented and challenged their version of the story, were deleted too.

Statistics

All in all, I ended up contacting 48 different publications in Germany, Austria, Switzerland, Belgium, Luxembourg, and the Netherlands. Some have overlapping editorial teams, in which case I only contacted them once. I kept track of the status of the correspondence with each of them in a spreadsheet, tracking: publication name, country, publish date, original source (DPA, RTL, BILD, etc), date first contacted, date last responded, response summary, and current outcome (removed/under review/no response/etc).

At the time of writing, here’s the breakdown of outcomes:

Total Contacted: 48

Outcome Count
Removals 27
Refused to Act 9
Under Review / Ongoing 7
No Response / Ignored 4
Not Contacted 1

What Worked

Persistence paid off. While there were a handful of editors that immediately took the DPA article down after I contacted them, the first reply from most was dismissive. Only after re-iterating and making clear that I was serious, understood what their responsibility was and prepared to escalate did some reconsider.

Escalation to the chief editor helped in a number of cases, and I was surprised by how many chief editors would respond when the main editorial address was non-responsive; I imagine this is a case of shared responsibility where it’s in nobody’s interest to take action and better to target a specific person.

Knowing the rules also did. A lot of the editors intentionally or unintentionally misunderstood my objections to the article, and framed them in terms that made them easier to dismiss.

Initially I was hesitant to go into details in my first email, instead assuming that I would trigger an investigation that would involve me being contacted for more information. Instead, I found that providing unequivocal documentation upfront made it more likely for editors to take action - and less likely to initially dismiss me.

The sequence of e-mails I sent the publications gradually increased in sternness, as I was hoping that not putting the journalists on the defensive immediately would make them more receptive. In hindsight, maybe I should have tried an A/B test to see whether a more direct approach would have been more effective than gradually building it up.

In many ways, it feels like what worked was to make it less effort to remove the article than to keep it up - moreso than the actual merits of the complaint. Where the DPA article was concerned, the fact they didn’t have an investment in the story meant papers had less incentive to fight for the article.

What I Learned

The economics of feel-good stories work against accuracy. These pieces are cheap to produce, travel well on social media, and generate engagement without controversy. Asking critical questions—”Is this actually how it happened?”-risks killing the story. No one has an incentive to do that.

Once an article is published, corrections become significantly harder. There are not many incentives to correct or retract articles, especially if they are performing well. It takes time, effort and persistence to get anything changed. Most editors either try to deflect responsibility, or simply ignore the complaints. Since my issue was journalistic ethics rather than legal, there was no legal pressure to act. The only real consequence is damage to reputation - but for that either the complainant has to venture into publicity or the press council has to get involved.

The spread of the original story took days. Getting it corrected or removed has taken weeks to months, is still ongoing, and will probably never be complete.

Journalistic standards exist, but invoking them as an outsider requires substantial documentation and persistence-they can otherwise be conveniently put aside. I was (naively) expecting the journalists I contacted to say “Thanks for pointing out the issue. Please provide proof and we’ll see whether we think we should issue a correction”. Even for the journalist who hadn’t written his article yet, I feel like I had to make it almost impossible while upholding journalistic standards for him to ignore the facts before he reconsidered.

Getting an article removed requires very little effort in some cases. A lot of papers removed the article after a single email from a random person on the internet. I’m assuming the barrier would have been higher for more newsworthy articles, but I don’t know that for sure.

Looking Back

It’s been weirdly fascinating experiencing how the media have dealt with this case. I’ve been surprised by how many “quality” media picked up the article despite it being quite sensational and having essentially zero news value. I almost respect how the original newspaper managed to squeeze three articles out of a story about something that happens hundreds of times a day.

In the grand scheme of things, my grievances about the article are minor - it is bad and lazy journalism, but small potatoes. Nobody is being falsely accused of murder. There are much more egregious examples out there.

I was already quite skeptical about most traditional media - articles about a field I have deep knowledge on (tech) often contain blatant and obvious inaccuracies, and spotting those always makes me wonder about the errors in articles relating to topics I don’t know anything about. If anything, this has made me more selective about what I read and share.

Previously I’d assumed that this was more due to incompetence and pushing political positions. After this experience, I’m left with the cynical impression that the incentives are for laziness and chasing clicks, with the story merely being a vehicle for that, even for bigger newspapers. I was expecting more care and accountability from the professional news media, but instead I got the same stances I would expect from a random blogger.

I’m curious what would have happened had these been original articles from each of the newspapers, rather than DPA articles, or if it had been concerning a topic with more news value rather than a human interest story.

Next Steps

If getting the record correct was more important to me than the privacy of those involved, I would have probably sought out publicity to make sure the full story would have gotten out there - but I don’t think that’s worth it.

I’m still following up with a few publications that have been slow to respond. I’ve also filed a formal complaint with the German press council about the disappointing response from DPA. My expectations for the complaint are low, but at least it creates a formal record and it might put some pressure on the DPA. It’s also free, fairly easy to do - and the identity of the complainant is kept confidential.

As for the smaller publications that have ignored me entirely, I may consider escalating those as well - it feels wrong to let them off the hook - but at the same time, I have to pick my battles.


  1. Projektteam Lokaljournalisten, Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung. Listed as “Chefredakteur Zeitungsgruppe Ostfriesland (Leer)”; the team has been in office since early 2019. ↩

  2. “Medien.Macht?Meinung! Wie Fake News die politische Öffentlichkeit verändern”, Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung, panel discussion in Oldenburg, 7 June 2017. “Man müsse in der heutigen Zeit noch mehr darauf achten, an einen herangetragene Informationen zu überprüfen”; “der Anspruch journalistischer Arbeit immer sei, die Wahrheit abzubilden”; traditional media “müssten lernen, stärker in den Dialog mit Leser_innen zu treten”. On deletions: the Nordwest-Zeitung deletes contributions “wenn diese eindeutig rechtswidrig, beispielsweise volksverhetzend, seien”. ↩

  3. Ziffer 1: Die Achtung vor der Wahrheit, die Wahrung der Menschenwürde und die wahrhaftige Unterrichtung der Öffentlichkeit sind oberste Gebote der Presse.” ↩

  4. Ziffer 2: “Recherche ist unverzichtbares Instrument journalistischer Sorgfalt. Zur Veröffentlichung bestimmte Informationen in Wort, Bild und Grafik sind mit der nach den Umständen gebotenen Sorgfalt auf ihren Wahrheitsgehalt zu prüfen und wahrheitsgetreu wiederzugeben. Ihr Sinn darf durch Bearbeitung, Überschrift oder Bildbeschriftung weder entstellt noch verfälscht werden. Unbestätigte Meldungen, Gerüchte und Vermutungen sind als solche erkennbar zu machen.” ↩

  5. Ziffer 3: “Veröffentlichte Nachrichten oder Behauptungen, insbesondere personenbezogener Art, die sich nachträglich als falsch erweisen, hat das Publikationsorgan, das sie gebracht hat, unverzüglich von sich aus in angemessener Weise richtig zu stellen.” ↩

Go Top